Annual fees: when they are worth paying

An annual fee is a yearly charge for keeping a card open. Some cards charge none, and others charge a modest or large amount in exchange for higher rewards or extra benefits. Whether the fee makes sense comes down to simple arithmetic: do the benefits you would really use add up to more than the fee?

What an annual fee is

The fee is listed in the rates-and-fees table that federal law requires on every card offer. It is usually billed once a year, often to your account balance, and some issuers waive it for the first year. Check what happens in year two, since that is when the full fee appears.

Federal rules also limit certain fees a card can charge in its first year, which matters most on cards with small limits. Penalty fees are treated separately.

The break-even math

Break-even is the point where what you gain equals what you pay. The formula is short: the value you receive in a year, minus what you would have received from a comparison card, minus the fee. If the result is above zero, the fee paid for itself.

Here is an example with invented numbers. Say a card has a $100 annual fee and includes a $60 yearly statement credit for a service you already pay for. If you would have bought that service anyway, the credit cuts the real cost of the fee to $40.

From there, the question is whether the other benefits you would use, such as rewards on your own spending, an extended warranty or travel protections, add up to more than the remaining $40. If they do not, the card costs more than it returns. Benefits and credits differ by card, so run your own numbers.

What to count and what to leave out

Count only value you would really capture. Statement credits are useful if you would have bought those things anyway. A credit for a service you never use is not a saving, even if it looks large on the list of benefits.

Be careful with sign-up bonuses. They are paid once, so they can make a first year look better than later years. Compare the card on the second-year math as well. It also helps to count points at a realistic value, based on how you would redeem them rather than the best case.

What else to compare

  • The no-fee alternative: what a card without a fee would earn on the same spending.
  • Interest: if you carry a balance, interest can cancel out any reward, with or without a fee.
  • Other charges: foreign transaction fees, balance transfer fees and penalty fees.
  • Fee timing: whether the fee is waived in year one and when it is billed.

If you carry a balance from month to month, a fee card is rarely the efficient choice, because interest tends to be larger than the extra rewards. You can read more about card costs on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau website, and browse the cards we reviewed to see how fees and rewards are structured.

If you decide the fee is not worth it

Some people ask the issuer whether the card can be changed to a no-fee version, which can keep the account open. Closing an account can affect your credit. Under the five FICO categories, amounts owed make up about 30 percent of a score and length of credit history about 15 percent, so closing an old card can raise your utilization, and over time the closed account may drop off your report and shorten your history. Weigh that before you cancel.

Key takeaways

  • An annual fee is worth paying only when the value you would really use is larger than the fee and the no-fee alternative.
  • Run the math with your own spending, and count sign-up bonuses and credits cautiously.
  • Before closing a card to avoid the fee, ask about a no-fee option and consider the effect on your credit history.

This article is for general information only and is not financial advice. Terms, rates and fees vary by issuer and lender, so check the official terms before you apply.

Money Mindly Team
Written by

Money Mindly Team