Cash back or points: how to match rewards to your spending
Rewards cards return a small share of what you spend as cash, credit or points. Which type fits depends on how you spend, how much effort you want to put in, and whether you pay the balance in full each month. Here is how the main reward styles work and what to compare.
Flat-rate cash back
A flat-rate card pays the same percentage on every purchase. There are no categories to track and no caps to watch. The reward is straightforward: spend $1,000 at a 1.5 percent rate and you earn $15.
This style is often described as simple, since there are no categories to track and the reward is the same wherever you spend. The trade-off is that the rate is often lower than what a category card pays in its best categories.
Category and rotating rewards
Category cards pay a higher rate on certain types of spending, such as groceries, dining or gas, and a lower rate on everything else. Some use categories that change every few months and require you to opt in.
The higher rate often comes with a spending cap. After you reach it, the rate drops. Say a card pays 5 percent on up to $1,500 of purchases per quarter. The most you earn at the top rate is $75 for that quarter. Check how much of your own spending actually falls into the bonus categories before the headline rate persuades you.
Points and miles
Points programs pay in a currency the issuer sets. Each point is worth a different amount depending on how you redeem it. Cash or statement credit usually gives a fixed value, while travel or gift card redemptions can be worth more or less per point.
To compare, work out the value of one point in cents. If 10,000 points buy a $100 statement credit, each point is worth one cent. If a travel redemption gives you $120 of value for the same points, the value is higher, but only if you would have booked that trip anyway. Programs can change point values or redemption options, sometimes with little notice, so check the rewards terms and how changes are announced.
When rewards are not worth it
Rewards only help when they are larger than what the card costs you. Several situations tip the balance the other way.
- Carrying a balance: interest can easily outweigh rewards. Say you earn $20 in rewards in a month but pay $35 in interest. You lost money.
- Overspending: buying more to earn more defeats the purpose.
- Annual fees: a fee that is larger than the rewards you earn is a net cost.
- Hard-to-use rewards: points you never redeem, or that lose value, return nothing.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau publishes consumer information about credit card terms, including rewards, on its website. Reward details, including earning caps and expiration rules, are part of the terms you agree to, so read them before relying on a promised rate.
How to compare your options
Start with your own statements. Add up a typical month of spending by type: groceries, gas, dining, bills and everything else. Then apply each card’s reward rates to those amounts and subtract any annual fee. The card that returns the most after costs is the better fit for that spending pattern, and the answer can change if your habits change.
Also consider how much work you will do. A card with several categories and sign-ups can beat a flat rate on paper, but only if you track it. If you would likely forget, a simple flat rate may return more in practice. You can also look at the cards we reviewed to see how reward structures differ.
Key takeaways
- Flat-rate cards are simple, category cards pay more on specific spending, and points depend on how you redeem them.
- Rewards lose their value when interest, fees or extra spending are larger than what you earn.
- Use your own statements to estimate what each reward style would return after fees.
This article is for general information only and is not financial advice. Terms, rates and fees vary by issuer and lender, so check the official terms before you apply.
